SYNOPSIS: This study assesses the influence of client gender and auditor gender on auditors’ judgments. In an experimental task, a client offers unverified explanations as to why the auditor’s initial proposed adjusting journal entry (AJE) to lower the inventory value should not be recorded. The design includes one randomly manipulated variable (client gender: male or female) and one measured variable (auditor gender: male or female). The dependent variable assesses the influence of the client’s explanations on the auditor’s final proposed AJE recommendation. The results indicate that both male and female auditors exhibited a male favorability; that is, they were persuaded more by a male than female client to change their initial AJE recommendation. Furthermore, female auditors were more influenced by a male client and less influenced by a female client than male auditors. Using an expert panel’s consensus opinion as a benchmark for the “best” solution, the male auditors were more accurate than female auditors, irrespective of client gender. Additional research will aid in substantiating, determining the limits, and generalizing the findings.

REFERENCES

REFERENCES
Almer
E. D.
,
Hopper
J. R.
, and
Kaplan
S. E.
1998
.
The effect of diversity-related attributes on hiring, advancement and voluntary turnover judgments
.
Accounting Horizons
12
(
1
):
1
17
.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA)
.
2006
. AICPA Work/Life and Women’s Initiatives 2004 Research. A Decade of Changes in the Accounting Profession: Workforce Trends and Human Capital Practices.
New York, NY:
AICPA
.
American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA)
.
2008
. 2008 Trends in the Supply of Accounting Graduates and the Demand for Public Accounting Recruits.
New York, NY:
AICPA
.
Anderson
J. C.
,
Johnson
E. N.
, and
Reckers
P. M. J.
1994
.
Perceived effects of gender, family structure and physical appearance on career progression in public accounting: A research note
.
Accounting, Organizations and Society
19
(
6
):
483
491
.
Anderson
U.
,
Koonce
L.
, and
Marchant
G.
1994
.
The effects of source-competence information and its timing on auditors’ performance of analytical procedures
.
Auditing: A Journal of Practice & Theory
13
(
1
):
137
148
.
Berger
J.
,
Fisek
M. H.
,
Norman
R. Z.
, and
Zelditch
M.
1977
. Status Characteristics and Social Interaction: An Expectation-States Approach.
New York, NY:
Elsevier
.
Biernat
M.
, and
Fuegen
K.
2001
.
Shifting standards and the evaluation of competence: Complexity in gender-based judgment and decision making
.
The Journal of Social Issues
57
(
4
):
707
724
.
Bluedorn
A. C.
1983
.
Attitudes and attributions toward women as managers and their performance
. Academy of Management Conference
:
397
401
.
Brenner
O. C.
, and
Beutell
N. J.
2001
.
The effect of birth order and gender and American managers’ attitudes toward female managers
.
The Journal of Social Psychology
129
(
1
):
57
64
.
Broder
I. E.
1993
.
Review of NSF Economics proposals: Gender and institutional patterns
.
The American Economic Review
83
(
4
):
964
970
.
Byrnes
J. P.
,
Miller
D. C.
, and
Schafer
W. D.
1999
.
Gender differences in risk raking: A meta-analysis
.
Psychological Bulletin
125
(
3
):
367
383
.
Carli
L. L.
1990
.
Gender, language and influence
.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
59
:
941
951
.
Carli
L. L.
2001
.
Gender and social influence
.
The Journal of Social Issues
57
(
4
):
725
741
.
Chung
J.
, and
Monroe
G. S.
1998
.
Gender differences in information processing: An empirical test of the hypothesis-confirming strategy in an audit context
.
Accounting and Finance
38
(
2
):
265
279
.
Chung
J.
, and
Monroe
G. S.
2001
.
A research note on the effects of gender and task complexity on an audit judgment
.
Behavioral Research in Accounting
13
:
111
125
.
Collins
K. M.
1993
.
Stress and departures from the public accounting profession: A study of gender differences
.
Accounting Horizons
7
(
1
):
29
38
.
Cordano
M.
,
Scherer
R. F.
, and
Owen
C. L.
2003
.
Dimensionality of the Women as Managers Scale: Factor congruency among three samples
.
The Journal of Social Psychology
143
(
1
):
141
143
.
Crino
M. D.
,
White
M. C.
, and
SeSanctis
G. L.
1981
.
A comment on the dimensionality and reliability of the Women as Managers Scale (WAMS)
.
Academy of Management Journal
24
(
4
):
866
876
.
Dennis
D. M.
, and
Engle
T. J.
1996
.
The effect of litigation on public accounting as a career choice
.
Accounting Horizons
10
(
2
):
1
13
.
Dunning
D.
, and
Sherman
D. A.
1997
.
Stereotypes and tacit inference
.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
73
(
3
):
459
471
.
Dwyer
P.
,
Gilkeson
J.
, and
List
J. A.
2002
.
Gender differences in revealed risk taking: Evidence from mutual fund investors
.
Economics Letters
76
(
2
):
151
158
.
Eagly
A. H.
,
Makhijani
M. G.
, and
Klonsky
B. G.
1992
.
Gender and the evaluation of leaders: A meta-analysis
.
Psychological Bulletin
111
:
3
22
.
Goldberg
J.
1968
.
Are women prejudiced against women?
Trans-Action
5
:
28
30
.
Greenwald
A. G.
, and
Banaji
M. R.
1995
.
Implicit social cognition: Attitudes, self-esteem, and stereotypes
.
Psychological Review
102
:
4
27
.
Hackenbrack
K.
1992
.
Implications of seemingly irrelevant evidence in audit judgment
.
Journal of Accounting Research
30
(
1
):
126
136
.
Harding
J. R.
,
Reding
K. F.
, and
Stocks
M. H.
2002
.
The effect of gender on the recruitment of entry-level accountants
.
Journal of Managerial Issues
14
(
2
):
251
266
.
Heilman
M. E.
,
Block
C.
,
Martell
R.
, and
Simon
M.
1989
.
Has anything changed? Current characterizations of males, females and managers
.
The Journal of Applied Psychology
74
:
935
942
.
Heilman
M. E.
,
Wallen
A. S.
,
Fuchs
D.
, and
Tankins
M. M.
2004
.
Penalties for success: Reactions to women who succeed at male gender-typed tasks
.
The Journal of Applied Psychology
89
(
3
):
416
427
.
Heilman
M. E.
, and
Chen
J. J.
2005
.
Same behavior, different consequences: Reactions to men’s and women’s altruistic citizenship behavior
.
The Journal of Applied Psychology
90
(
3
):
431
441
.
Hinz
R. P.
,
McCarthy
D. D.
, and
Turner
J. A.
1997
.
Are women conservative investors? Gender differences in participant-directed pension investments
.
In
Positioning Pensions for the Twenty-First Century,
edited by
Gordon
, ,
Mitchell
O. S.
, and
Twinney
M. M.
,
91
103
.
Philadelphia, PA:
University of Pennsylvania Press
.
Hull
R. P.
, and
Umansky
P. H.
1997
.
An examination of gender stereotyping as an explanation for vertical job segregation in public accounting
.
Accounting, Organizations and Society
22
(
6
):
507
528
.
Jianakoplos
N. A.
, and
Bernasek
A.
1998
.
Are women more risk averse?
Economic Inquiry
36
(
4
):
620
630
.
Johnson
E. N.
,
Kaplan
S. E.
, and
Reckers
P. M. J.
1998
.
An examination of potential gender-based differences in audit managers’ performance evaluation judgments
.
Behavioral Research in Accounting
10
:
47
75
.
Lockheed
M. E.
1985
.
Sex and social influence: A meta-analysis guided by theory
.
In
Status, Rewards, and Influence: How Expectations Organize Behavior,
edited by
Berger
, , and
Zelditch
M.
,
406
429
.
San Francisco, CA:
Jossey-Bass
.
Mathison
D. L.
1986
.
Sex differences in the perception of assertiveness among female managers
.
The Journal of Social Psychology
126
(
5
):
599
606
.
Meyers-Levy
J.
1989
.
Gender differences in information processing: A selectivity interpretation
.
In
Cognitive and Affective Responses to Advertising,
edited by
Cafferata
P.
, and
Tybout
A.
,
219
260
.
Lexington, MA:
Lexington
.
Meyers-Levy
J.
, and
Maheswaran
D.
1991
.
Exploring differences in males’ and females’ processing strategy
.
The Journal of Consumer Research
18
(
1
):
63
70
.
Meyers-Levy
J.
, and
Sternthal
B.
1991
.
Gender differences in the use of message cues and judgments
.
Journal of Marketing Research
28
:
84
96
.
Meyers-Levy
J.
1998
.
Mixed messages: How men and women differ in their responses to marketing messages
. Capital Ideas
1
(
3
).
http://www.chicagogsb.edu/capideas/sum98/meyers.htm
.
Norton
M. I.
,
Vandello
J. A.
, and
Darley
J. M.
2004
.
Casuistry and social category bias
.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
87
(
6
):
817
831
.
No¨teberg
A.
, and
Hunton
J. E.
2005
.
Client inquiry via electronic communication media: Does the medium matter?
Advances in Accounting Behavioral Research
8
:
87
112
.
Nyberg-Stuart
A.
2006
.
What women want
.
CFO Magazine
22
(
7
):
46
54
.
O’Donnell
E.
, and
Johnson
E. N.
2001
.
The effects of auditor gender and task complexity on information processing efficiency
.
International Journal of Auditing
5
(
2
):
91
105
.
Olsen
R. A.
, and
Cox
C. M.
2001
.
The influence of gender on the perception and response to investment risk: The case of professional investors
.
Journal of Psychology and Financial Markets
2
(
1
):
29
36
.
Owen
C. L.
, and
Todor
W. D.
1993
.
Attitudes toward women as managers: Still the same
.
Business Horizons
36
(
2
):
12
16
.
Peters
L. H.
,
Terborg
J. R.
, and
Taynor
J.
1974
.
Women as Managers Scale (WAMS): A measure of attitudes toward women in management positions
. JSAS Catalog of Selected Documents in Psychology
4
(
27
).
Pillsbury
C.
,
Capozzoli
L.
, and
Ciampa
A.
1989
.
A synthesis of research studies regarding the upward mobility of women in public accounting
.
Accounting Horizons
3
(
1
):
63
70
.
Powell
G. N.
, and
Butterfield
D. A.
1989
.
The “good manager:” Did androgyny fare better in the 1980s?
Group and Organizational Studies
14
:
216
233
.
Propp
K. M.
1995
.
An experimental examination of biological sex as a status cue in decision-making groups and its influence on information use
.
Small Group Research
26
:
451
474
.
Ragins
B. R.
, and
Cotton
J. L.
1993
.
Gender and willingness to mentor in organizations
.
Journal of Management
19
(
1
):
97
111
.
Rudman
L. A.
1998
.
Self-promotion as a risk factor for women: The costs and benefits of counterstereotypical impression management
.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
74
(
3
):
629
645
.
Rudman
L. A.
, and
Glick
P.
1999
.
Feminized management and backlash toward agentic women: The hidden costs to women of a kinder, gentler image of middle managers
.
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology
77
(
5
):
1004
1010
.
Rudman
L. A.
, and
Kilianski
S. E.
2000
.
Implicit and explicit attitudes toward female authority
.
Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin
26
(
11
):
1315
1328
.
Schein
V. E.
, and
Mueller
R.
1992
.
Sex role stereotyping and requisite management characteristics: A cross-cultural look
.
Journal of Organizational Behavior
13
:
439
447
.
Schein
V. E.
,
Mueller
R.
,
Lituchy
T.
, and
Liu
J.
1996
.
Think manager—think male: A global phenomenon?
Journal of Organizational Behavior
17
:
33
41
.
Schein
V. E.
2001
.
A global look at psychological barriers to women’s progress in management
.
The Journal of Social Issues
57
(
4
):
675
688
.
Schneider
J.
, and
Cook
K.
1995
.
Status inconsistency and gender
.
Small Group Research
26
:
372
399
.
Sunde´n
A. E.
, and
Surette
B. J.
1998
.
Gender differences in the allocation of assets in retirement savings plans
.
The American Economic Review
88
(
2
):
207
211
.
Terborg
J. R.
,
Peters
L. H.
,
Ilgen
D. R.
, and
Smith
F.
1977
.
Organizational and personal correlates of attitudes toward women as managers
.
Academy of Management Journal
20
(
1
):
89
100
.
Trapp
M.
,
Hermanson
R.
, and
Turner
D.
1989
.
Current perceptions of issues related to women employed in public accounting
.
Accounting Horizons
3
(
1
):
71
85
.
Wagner
D. G.
, and
Berger
J.
1997
.
Sex and interpersonal task behaviors: Status expectations accounts
.
Sociological Perspectives
40
(
1
):
1
32
.
Williams
J. E.
, and
Best
D. L.
1990
. Measuring Sex Stereotypes: A Multination Study.
Beverly Hills, CA:
Sage
.
Young
S. M.
1985
.
Participative budgeting: The effects of risk aversion and asymmetric information on budgetary slack
.
Journal of Accounting Research
23
(
2
):
829
842
.
This content is only available as a PDF.