This paper explores the political, legal, and ethical issues at stake in the debate over the custody of the Iraqi Baath Party records. The dispute over the records' past and discussion about their future reveals a larger political struggle over the custody of records seized during wartime. Prevailing international law deems these records cultural property and provides legal guidelines for their treatment and return. Ethical arguments in favor of the seizure highlight the protection of the records as well as their accessibility to international researchers and human rights lawyers, while arguments against the seizure stress the importance of the records to the formation of national identity and nation-building in Iraq. Underlying the political, legal, and ethical arguments surrounding these records are two contrasting views of cultural property: on the one hand, cultural property is seen as an expression of national rights to which members of a nation are entitled, and, on the other hand, access to cultural property is seen as a universal human right to which all people, regardless of national affiliation, are entitled. This paper concludes by suggesting a third, postcolonial approach to cultural property.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
Research Article|
July 09 2011
"Thank You Very Much, Now Give Them Back": Cultural Property and the Fight over the Iraqi Baath Party Records
The American Archivist (2011) 74 (1): 211–240.
Citation
Mary Pugh, Michelle Caswell; "Thank You Very Much, Now Give Them Back": Cultural Property and the Fight over the Iraqi Baath Party Records. The American Archivist 1 April 2011; 74 (1): 211–240. doi: https://doi.org/10.17723/aarc.74.1.4185u8574mu84041
Download citation file:
Citing articles via
Get Email Alerts
Level Up! Lessons Learned from Six Years of Collaborative Technical Skills Development
Max Eckard, Elizabeth Gadelha, Mike Shallcross
Redesigning Program Assessment for Teaching with Primary Sources: Understanding the Impacts of Our Work
Jen Hoyer, Kaitlin Holt, John Voiklis, Bennett Attaway, Rebecca Joy Norlander
Tales from “THE disK FILES”: Lessons Learnt from a Data Recovery Project in 2003–2006 at the National Archives of Australia
David Pearson, FSA, James Doig
The Social Movement Archive
Lori Podolsky