In this article, Michelle J. Bellino explores contrasting approaches to civic education in two rural schools serving indigenous Maya youth in post–civil war Guatemala. Through comparative ethnography, she examines how youth civic pathways intersect with legacies of authoritarianism while young people shape their identity as members of historically oppressed groups. She suggests that student decisions about how and when to participate in civic issues function as a risk calculus, taking into consideration the costs and benefits of both participation and nonparticipation as well as the civic obligation to abstain or join communities in struggle. Although serving similarly impoverished communities hard-hit by state actors during the war and now struggling with issues of indigenous autonomy, both schools position daily experiences with injustice as an entry point for constructing youth citizenship. Beyond this shared experience of historical injustice and its ongoing effects, educators envision young peoples' roles according to different risk structures. In this way, youth construct civic pathways while traversing between the potential for risk and reward, in part informed by their experiences in school.
Skip Nav Destination
Research Article| December 01 2015
The Risks We Are Willing to Take: Youth Civic Development in “Postwar” Guatemala
Harvard Educational Review (2015) 85 (4): 537–561.
- Views Icon Views
- Share Icon Share
- Search Site
Michelle J. Bellino; The Risks We Are Willing to Take: Youth Civic Development in “Postwar” Guatemala. Harvard Educational Review 1 December 2015; 85 (4): 537–561. doi: https://doi.org/10.17763/0017-8055.85.4.537
Download citation file:
Citing articles via
Beyond the Bus: Reconceptualizing School Transportation for Mobility Justice
SARAH WINCHELL LENHOFF, JEREMY SINGER, KIMBERLY STOKES, JAMES BEAR MAHOWALD, SAHAR KHAWAJA
“Reinventing Ourselves” and Reimagining Education: Everyday Learning and Life Lessons from the COVID-19 Pandemic
MARJORIE FAULSTICH ORELLANA, LU LIU, SOPHIA L. ÁNGELES
ALYSHA BANERJI, ABHINAV GHOSH, ALYSSA NAPIER, SANTIAGO PULIDO-GÓMEZ, MEKKA A. SMITH