In 2017, Hurricane María left more than a third of Puerto Rican households without water services. Cascading failures—including the simultaneous collapse of water, electricity, and transportation sectors—presented serious challenges to the timely restoration of governmental services. In response, families across Puerto Rico adopted self-organized coping strategies to obtain the basic resources they needed, including safe and sufficient water. Drawing on the fast-growing literature on household water sharing, we examine how Puerto Rican families shared water as a response to disaster. Using participant-observation data, interviews, and social network data, we studied water-sharing networks in three municipalities—urban, peri-urban, and rural—in western Puerto Rico in the aftermath of Hurricane María. We found that extensive water sharing (in 85% of households) spontaneously emerged in the wake of disaster, in previously water-secure rural, peri-urban, and urban communities. Households relied primarily on kin and neighbors, and women had more extensive sharing networks than men. Water-sharing arrangements were typically a form of generalized reciprocity, with little expectation of direct payback. We conclude that water-sharing networks are an important—but understudied and underutilized—component of disaster response. Our research indicates that water sharing should be more explicitly planned for and included in disaster preparedness plans. If water sharing is the dominant approach for coping with disaster-induced water insecurity, we argue, it must be at the core of disaster response.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
Fall 2023
Research Article|
August 24 2023
WATER SHARING AS DISASTER RESPONSE: COPING WITH WATER INSECURITY AFTER HURRICANE MARÍA
Anaís Roque;
Anaís Roque
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Amber Wutich;
Amber Wutich
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Alexandra Brewis;
Alexandra Brewis
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Melissa Beresford;
Melissa Beresford
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Hilda Lloréns;
Hilda Lloréns
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Carlos García-Quijano;
Carlos García-Quijano
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Wendy Jepson
Wendy Jepson
Anaís Roque is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at The Ohio State University. Her community-engaged research investigates household and community experiences with food, energy, and water insecurity in disaster contexts. Amber Wutich is an anthropologist, President’s Professor, and Director of the Center for Global Health at Arizona State University. Her cross-cultural and community-based fieldwork examines the impacts of inequitable and unjust water institutions on people’s well-being. Alexandra Brewis is President’s Professor at Arizona State University. As a biocultural and medical anthropologist, her interests focus on anthropological approaches to solving major health and environmental challenges, including stigma and water insecurity. Melissa Beresford is an Assistant Professor of Anthropology at San José State University. Her research investigates the social institutions that humans use to respond to water insecurity. Hilda Lloréns is an Associate Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. Her research, writing, and teaching focus on race, gender, ecology, culture, and power in the Americas. Carlos G. García-Quijano is a Professor in the Departments of Sociology/Anthropology & Marine Affairs at the University of Rhode Island. His scholarship focuses on how cognition, culture, and society influence the interaction between people and the ecosystems they form part of, especially along coasts. Wendy Jepson is a geographer, University Professor, and Associate Director of the Texas Water Resources Institute at Texas A&M University. Her research examines contemporary debates in human-environment interactions, water security, and water governance.
Search for other works by this author on:
Human Organization (2023) 82 (3): 248–260.
Citation
Anaís Roque, Amber Wutich, Alexandra Brewis, Melissa Beresford, Hilda Lloréns, Carlos García-Quijano, Wendy Jepson; WATER SHARING AS DISASTER RESPONSE: COPING WITH WATER INSECURITY AFTER HURRICANE MARÍA. Human Organization 1 September 2023; 82 (3): 248–260. doi: https://doi.org/10.17730/1938-3525-82.3.248
Download citation file:
Sign in
Don't already have an account? Register
Client Account
You could not be signed in. Please check your email address / username and password and try again.
Could not validate captcha. Please try again.
Sign in via your Institution
Sign in via your InstitutionCiting articles via
MPAs AS PROTECTED DESTINATIONS: RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN OUTDOOR RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES, INCLUDING FISHING, AND PERCEPTIONS OF MARINE RESERVES IN PUGET SOUND, WASHINGTON, UNITED STATES
Marc L. Miller, Richard B. Pollnac, Patrick J. Christie
RESPONSIBLE DRIVING IN THE AGE OF SMARTPHONES: APPLIED RESEARCH FOR IMPROVING ROAD SAFETY IN THE MOTOR CITY
Yuson Jung, Andrea Sankar, Kaitlin Carter, Yen-Ting Chang, Bianca Dean, Travis Kruso, Colleen Linn, Emily Lock, Craig Meiners, Molly Sanford, Haley Scott, Jasmine Walker
EDITORIAL: KEEPING PACE
Lenore Manderson