ABSTRACT
The applicability of building rating systems has gained attention for achieving indoor environmental quality. Considering the wider internationalized recognition of LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) and other rating systems, the case of Jordan provides a sense of particularity in consideration to its rather recent history in acknowledging these progressive standards. Utilizing a mixed approach based on paired comparisons between local LEED and non-LEED certified buildings, this research paper explores the level of satisfaction pertaining to Indoor Environmental Quality of building occupants. While it touches on the generality of such satisfaction, it proceeds to unpack and investigate how it resonates with the sustainability of the building measured through various means. The research outcomes reflected an overall appeal of LEED certified buildings and a decent level of comfort of their dwellers. Yet, it conveyed a vague, rather sporadic relation when comparing the subjective perception to the objective measures due to multiple potential reasons. The paper concludes by stressing the need for further appropriation of international environmental codes to better suit the local context. It lays a reliable foundation for further research, utilizing more case studies and exploring the applicability of rating systems in Jordan.
REFERENCES
Abbaszadeh,
S.,
Zagreus,
L.,
Lehrer,
D.,
Huizenga,
C.
2006
).
“Occupant satisfaction with indoor environmental quality in green buildings.”
Proceedings of Healthy Buildings 2006
,
Lisbon
,
365
–
370
.
Adami,
M.,
Kiger,
A.
2005
).
“The use of triangulation for completeness purposes.”
Nurse Researcher
, 12,
19
–
29
.
Al-Atrash,
F.,
Hellwig,
R.,
Wagner,
A.
2018
).
“Personal Control over Indoor Climate in Office Buildings in a Mediterranean Climate—Amman, Jordan.”
Proceedings of Windsor Conference ‘Rethinking Comfort’
,
269
–
314
.
Altomonte,
S.,
Saadouni,
S.,
Schiavon,
S.
2016
).
“Occupant Satisfaction in LEED and BREEAM-certified Office Buildings.”
Proceedings of the PLEA 2016, 36th International Conference on Passive and Low Energy Architecture: Cities, Buildings, People: Towards Regenerative Environments
,
Los Angeles
.
Altomonte,
S.,
Schiavon,
S.,
Kent,
M.,
Brager,
G.
2019
).
“Indoor environmental quality and occupant satisfaction in green-certified buildings.”
Building Research and Information
,
47
(
3
),
255
–
274
.
Altomonte,
S.,
Schiavon,
S.
2013
).
“Occupant satisfaction in LEED and non-LEED certified buildings.”
Building and Environment
, 68,
66
–
76
.
Arens,
E.,
Xu,
T.,
Miura,
K.,
Zhang,
H.,
Fountain,
M.,
Bauman,
F.
1998
).
“A study of occupant cooling by personally controlled air movement.”
Energy and Buildings
,
27
(
1
),
45
–
59
.
Astolfi,
A.,
Pellerey,
F.
2008
).
“Subjective and objective assessment of acoustical and overall environmental quality in secondary school classrooms.”
The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America
, 123,
163
–
173
.
Baird,
G.,
Leaman,
A.,
Thompson,
J.
2012
).
“A comparison of the performance of sustainable buildings with conventional buildings from the point of view of the users.”
Architectural Science Review
, 55,
135
–
144
.
Berardi,
U.
2017
).
“A cross-country comparison of the building energy consumptions and their trends.”
Resources Conservation and Recycling
, 123,
230
–
241
.
Bluyssen,
P.
2014
).
The Healthy Indoor Environment: How to Assess Occupants’ Wellbeing in Buildings
.
Routledge, Oxon
.
Brager,
G.,
Paliaga,
G.,
de Dear,
R.
2004
).
“Operable windows, personal control, and occupant comfort.”
ASHRAE Transactions
,
110
(
2
),
17
–
35
.
Brown,
Z.,
Cole,
R.,
Robinson,
J.,
Dowlatabadi,
H.
2010
).
“Evaluating user experience in green buildings in relation to workplace culture and context.”
Facilities
,
28
(
3
),
225
–
238
.
Cakmak,
S.,
Dales,
R.,
Liu,
L.,
Kauri,
L.,
Lemieux,
C.,
Hebbern,
C.,
Zhu,
J.
2014
).
“Residential exposure to volatile organic compounds and lung function: Results from a population-based cross-sectional survey.”
Environmental Pollution
, 194,
145
–
151
.
Candido,
C.,
Kim,
J.,
de Dear,
R.,
Thomas,
L.
2016
).
“BOSSA: a multidimensional post-occupancy evaluation tool.”
Building Research and Information
,
44
(
2
),
214
–
228
.
Cohen,
J.
1988
).
Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences
.
Lawrence Earlbaum Associates
,
Hillsdale
.
De Giuli,
V.,
Da Pos,
O.,
De Carli,
M.
2012
).
“Indoor environmental quality and pupil perception in Italian primary schools.”
Building and Environment
, 56,
335
–
345
.
De Giuli,
V.,
Zecchin,
R.,
Corain,
L.,
Salmaso,
L.
2014
).
“Measured and perceived environmental comfort: field monitoring in an Italian school.”
Applied Ergonomics
,
45
(
4
),
1035
–
1047
.
EcoMena.
(
2017
).
“Green building rating systems in MENA.”
Green Building, Middle East
, <
https://www.ecomena.org/green-building-mena/> (Jan. 15, 2018).
Firestone,
W.
1993
).
“Alternative arguments for generalizing from data, as applied to qualitative research.”
Educational Researcher
,
22
(
4
),
16
–
23
.
Frontczak,
M.,
Schiavon,
S.,
Goins,
J.,
Arens,
E.,
Zhang,
H.,
Wargocki,
P.
2012
).
“Quantitative relationships between occupant satisfaction and satisfaction aspects of indoor environmental quality and building design.”
Indoor Air
,
22
,
131
–
119
.
Frontczak,
M.,
Wargocki,
P.
2011
).
“Literature survey on how different factors influence human comfort in indoor environments.”
Building and Environment
, 46,
922
–
937
.
Geng,
Y.,
Ji,
W.,
Lin,
B.,
Zhu,
Y.
2017
).
“The impact of thermal environment on occupant IEQ perception and productivity.”
Building and Environment
,
121
,
158
–
167
.
Gonzalez,
A.,
Diaz,
J.,
Caamano,
A.,
Wilby,
M.
2011
).
“Towards a universal energy efficiency index for buildings.”
Energy and Buildings
,
40
,
980
–
987
.
Goodrick,
D.
2014
).
Comparative Case Studies: Methodological Briefs—Impact Evaluation No. 9
.
Methodological Briefs, UNICEF
,
Florence
.
Haldi,
F.,
Robinson,
D.
2011
).
“The impact of occupants’ behaviour on building energy demand.”
Journal of Building Performance Simulation
,
4
(
4
),
323
–
338
.
Hedge,
A.,
Miller,
L.,
Dorsey,
J.
2014
).
“Occupant comfort and health in green and conventional university buildings.”
Work
,
49
,
363
–
372
.
Heinzerling,
D.,
Schiavon,
S.,
Webster,
T.,
Arens,
E.
2013
).
“Indoor environmental quality evaluation through objective and subjective measurement models: a literature review and a proposed weighting and classification scheme.”
Building and Environment
,
Huizenga,
C.,
Zagreus,
L.,
Abbaszadeh,
S.,
Lehrer,
D.,
Goins,
J.,
Hoe,
L.,
Arens,
E.
2005
).
“LEED post-occupancy evaluation: taking responsibility for the occupants.”
Proceedings of Greenbuild
,
9–11 November, 2005
,
Atlanta
.
Humphreys,
M.,
Nicol,
J.
2007
).
“Self-assessed productivity and the office environment: monthly surveys in five European countries.”
ASHRAE Transactions
,
113
,
606
–
617
.
International Energy Agency, and the United Nations Environment Programme
(
2018
) .
2018 Global Status Report: Towards a Zero-emission, Efficient and Resilient Buildings and Construction Sector
.
Institute of Medicine.
(
2011
).
Climate Change, the Indoor Environment, and Health
.
The National Academies Press
,
Washington DC
.
IPCC.
(
2014
).
Climate Change in 2014: Synthesis Report
.
Geneva
.
Issa,
M.,
Rankin,
J.,
Attalla,
M.,
Christian,
A.
2011
).
“Absenteeism, performance and occupant satisfaction with the indoor environment of green Toronto schools.”
Indoor and Built Environment
,
20
(
5
),
511
–
523
Jones,
K.,
Stegemann,
J.,
Sykes,
J.,
Winslow,
P.
2016
).
“Adoption of unconventional approaches in construction: the case of cross-laminated timber.”
Construction and Building Material
,
125
,
690
–
702
.
Jordan Green Building Council
(
2017
).
Your Guide to Green Building in Jordan
.
JGBC
,
Amman
.
Kennedy,
M.
1979
).
“Generalizing from single case studies.”
Evaluation Quarterly
,
3
,
661
–
678
.
Khashe,
S.,
Heydarian,
A.,
Gerber,
D.,
Becerik-Gerber,
B.,
Hayes,
T.,
Wood,
W.
2015
).
“Influence of LEED branding on building occupants’ pro-environmental behavior.”
Building and Environment
,
94
,
477
–
488
.
Khoshbakht,
M.,
Gou,
Z.,
Dupre,
K.,
Best,
R.
2018
).
“Occupant satisfaction and comfort in green buildings: a longitudinal occupant survey in a green building in the subtropical climate in Australia.”
Proceedings of the 52nd International Conference of the Architectural Science Association 2018
,
Melbourne
,
371
–
381
.
Kim,
J.,
De Dear
R.
2013
).
“Workspace satisfaction: the privacy–communication trade-off in open-plan offices.”
Journal of Environmental Psychology
,
36
,
18
–
26
.
Kim,
S.,
Hwang,
Y.,
Lee,
Y.,
Corser,
W.
2015
).
“Occupant comfort and satisfaction in green healthcare environments: a survey study focusing on healthcare staff.”
Journal of Sustainable Development
,
8
(
1
),
156
–
173
.
Kim,
J.,
Kim,
S.,
Yang,
I.,
Kim,
K.
2008
).
“A design support system for effective planning of the integrated workplace performance.”
Building and Environment
,
43
,
1286
–
1300
.
Konis,
K.
2013
).
“Evaluating daylighting effectiveness and occupant visual comfort in a side-lit open-plan office building in San Francisco, California.”
Building and Environment
,
59
,
662
–
677
.
Laskari,
M.,
Karatasou,
S.,
Santamouris,
M.
2017
).
“A methodology for the determination of indoor environmental quality in residential buildings through the monitoring of fundamental environmental parameters: A proposed Dwelling Environmental Quality Index.”
Indoor and Built Environment
,
26
(
6
),
813
–
827
.
Leaman,
A.,
Bordass,
B.
1999
).
“Productivity in buildings: the killer variable.”
Building Research and Information
,
27
(
2
),
4
–
19
.
Leder,
S.,
Newsham,
G.,
Veitch,
J.,
Mancini,
S.,
Charles,
K.
2016
).
“Effects of office environment on employee satisfaction: a new analysis.”
Building Research and Information
,
44
,
34
–
50
.
Lee,
Y.,
Guerin,
D.
2009
).
“Indoor environmental quality related to occupant satisfaction and performance in LEED-certified buildings.”
Journal of Indoor and Built Environment
,
18
(
4
),
293
–
300
.
Lee,
Y.,
Kim,
S.
2008
).
“Indoor environmental quality in LEED-certified buildings in the U.S.”
Journal of Asian Architecture and Building Engineering
,
7
(
2
),
293
–
300
.
Lee,
J.,
Wargocki,
P.,
Chan,
Y.,
Chen,
L.,
Tham,
K.
2019
).
“Indoor environmental quality, occupant satisfaction, and acute building-related health symptoms in green mark-certified compared with non-certified office buildings.”
Indoor Air
,
29
,
112
–
129
.
Ma,
J.,
Cheng,
J.
2016
).
“Data-driven study on the achievement of LEED credits using percentage of average score and association rule analysis.”
Building and Environment
,
98
,
121
–
132
.
Mendler,
S.,
Odell,
W.,
Lazarus,
M.
2005
).
The HOK Guidebook to Sustainable Design
.
Wiley, Indianapolis
.
Monahan,
J.,
Powell,
J.
2011
).
“An embodied carbon and energy analysis of modern methods of construction in housing: a case study using a lifecycle assessment framework.”
Energy and Buildings
,
43
,
179
–
188
.
Moore,
D.,
McCabe,
G.
2002
).
Introduction to the practice of statistics
.
W. H. Freeman
,
New York
.
Newsham,
G.,
Birt,
B.,
Arsenault,
C.,
Thompson,
A.,
Veitch,
J.,
Mancini,
S.,
Galasiu,
A.,
Gover,
B.,
Macdonald,
I.,
Burns,
G.
2013
).
“Do ‘green’ buildings have better indoor environments? new evidence.”
Building Research and Information
,
41
,
415
–
434
.
Onwuegbuzie,
A.,
Collins,
K.
2007
).
“A typology of mixed methods sampling designs in social science research.”
The Qualitative Report
,
12
(
2
),
281
–
316
.
Paul,
W.,
Taylor,
P.
2008
).
“A comparison of occupant comfort and satisfaction between a green building and a conventional building.”
Building and Environment
,
43
(
11
),
1858
–
1870
.
Portman,
A.,
Clevenger,
C.,
France,
C.
2006
).
Using LEED-NC in Colorado: Tips, Resources, and Examples
.
Colorado Governor’s Office of Energy and Management and Conservation
,
Colorado
.
Radwan,
A.,
Issa,
M.,
Mallory-Hill,
S.
2013
).
“A review of research investigating indoor environmental quality in green buildings.”
Proceedings of Portugal-Sustainable Building Contribution to Achieve the EU 20-20-20 Targets
,
Guimaraes
,
497
–
504
.
Robichaud,
L.,
Anantatmula,
V.
2011
).
“Greening project management practices for sustainable construction.”
Journal of Management in Engineering
, 27,
48
–
57
.
Rosenlund,
H.,
Emtairah,
T.,
Visser,
F.
2010
).
“Building green in Jordan? Performance evaluation of the Aqaba Residential Energy Efficiency pilot project (AREE).”
Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Sustainable Architecture and Urban Development 2010
,
Amman
.
Sadick,
A.
2018
).
“Assessment of school buildings’ physical conditions and indoor environmental quality in relation to teachers’ satisfaction and well-being.”
PhD, University of Manitoba
.
Sanders,
P.,
Collins,
B.
1995
).
Post-occupancy Evaluation of the Forrestal Building
.
Prepared for US Department of Energy
,
Washington DC
.
Schiavon,
S.,
Altomonte,
S.
2014
).
“Influence of factors unrelated to environmental quality on occupant satisfaction in LEED and non-LEED certified buildings.”
Building and Environment
, 77,
148
–
159
.
Shareef,
S.,
Altan,
H.
2017
).
“Building sustainability rating systems in the Middle East.”
Proceedings of the Institute of Civil Engineers—Engineering Sustainability
,
170
,
283
–
293
.
Sharif,
A.
2016
).
“Sustainable architectural design between inscription and de-scription: the case of Masdar City.”
PhD, University of Manchester
.
Thatcher,
A.,
Milner,
K.
2016
).
“Is a green building really better for building occupants? a longitudinal evaluation.”
Building and Environment
,
108
,
194
–
206
.
Tsushima,
S.,
Tanabe,
S.,
Utsumi,
K.
2015
).
“Workers’ awareness and indoor environmental quality in electricity saving offices.”
Building and Environment
,
88
,
10
–
19
.
USGBC
(
2017
).
“LEED v4 for Building Design and Construction.”
<http://www.usgbc.org/sites/default/files/LEED20v420BDC_01.27.17_current.pdf> (Feb. 17, 2017).
Webster,
T.,
Heinzerling,
D.,
Anwar,
G.
2013
).
A Prototype Toolkit for Evaluating Indoor Environmental Quality in Commercial Buildings
.
Final Report, Energy Research and Development Division
,
UC Berkeley
.
Young,
S.,
Lee,
A.,
Denise,
A.,
Guerin,
B.
2010
).
“Indoor environmental quality differences between office types in LEED-certified buildings in the US.”
Building and Environment
,
45
,
1104
–
1112
.
Zhang,
H.,
Arens,
A.,
Kim,
D.,
Buchberger,
E.,
Bauman,
F.,
Huizenga,
C.
2010
).
“Comfort, perceived air quality, and work performance in a low-power task-ambient conditioning system.”
Building and Environment
,
45
(
1
),
29
–
39
.
Zhang,
H.,
Arens,
E.,
Zhai,
Y.
2015
).
“A review of the corrective power of personal comfort systems in non-neutral ambient environments.”
Building and Environment
,
91
,
15
–
41
.
This content is only available as a PDF.
Author notes
1. Professor, Department of Architecture, Jordan University of Science and Technology, [email protected]
2. Researcher, Department of Architecture, College of Architecture and Design, Jordan University of Science and Technology, [email protected]
3. Assistant Professor, Department of Architectural Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, The Hashemite University, [email protected]