We have measured survival after successive 2-Gy doses of X rays in HeLa cells and 1-Gy doses in cells of the nonimmortalized human fibroblast cell line AG15-22 under conditions where any effect of cell proliferation during multifraction X irradiation has been factored out. When HeLa cells in parallel series of (pseudo)hybrid spheroids (i.e. in agglomerates consisting of a mixture of supralethally irradiated HeLa feeder and viable HeLa cells) were exposed to n daily radiation doses and then trypsinized and exposed to the last dose, the surviving fraction at 2 Gy (SF2) declined exponentially from 0.55 ± 0.01 to 0.31 ± 0.01 after the fifth fraction. In monolayer HeLa cell cultures, the decline in SF2 was smaller but significant and was not influenced by the presence of feeder cells. Pure spheroids, composed entirely of viable HeLa cells, showed the same decline in SF2 as did monolayer cells. The cumulative-effect curve (i.e. the product of SF2 values) was linear-quadratic with the quadratic term increasing in the order monolayer, pure spheroids, pseudohybrid spheroids.${\rm SF}2^{{\rm n}}$ and$D_{0\ {\rm Eff}}$ (deduced from the initial SF2) severely underestimated cumulative radiosensitivity. This cumulative effect is clearly associated with the proximity of lethally irradiated cells and might be explained by differential population shifts in the course of the multifraction regimen. Similarly, AG15-22 cells irradiated with daily 1-Gy doses of X rays showed a larger increase in radiosensitivity when in hybrid spheroids than when in pure spheroids. However, for the AG15-22 cells, SF1 was twofold lower for the former than for the latter condition and remained constant for both conditions rather than decreasing with increasing fraction number. This large radiosensitizing effect remains unexplained.

This content is only available as a PDF.